I'm turning to my fellow know-it-alls for the answer to this question: Are my broken sump pumps recyclable or do they go in the garbage? I use dirty water sump pumps to circulate the water through a filter for my snapping turtle. Because they run day and night, they don't last long. I get maybe one full winter, spring, summer, autumn season out of one pump. The shelf in my garage that holds all these broken down pumps is full and sagging, so I'd like to put them out for the garbage collector. Hence my dilemma. Our city has three trash receptacles - garbage, recycle and green waste. Which receptacle do I put the pumps in?