I have been told to use paper towels or news paper as a substrate for the first couple of weeks or should I go ahead and get the orchard
I keep my brand new hatchlings on damp paper towels in plastic shoe boxes for the first 7-10 day after hatching. After they absorb their yolk sac and the umbilical scar closes up, I move them onto orchid bark in a closed chamber enclosure.
If you are going to use paper towels, they should be damp and the whole enclosure kept warm 24/7. You will also need to keep greens in there to make sure they don't eat the paper towels.
Personally, with your tortoises age, I would go straight to orchid bark, but there can't be a colored bulb in there when you do and hopefully the coil bulb didn't do too much damage.