Through the years I have had many box turtles, but only two tortoises. I have never had any of either species that like to be held or petted. If I am working in my garden...weeding...cleaning up..digging, there isn't one box turtle that won't come over to investigate. Some will actually lean on my hand that is digging or doing...whatever. Pio, my oldest tortoise will come to see what I'm doing, especially if I'm planting a new plant, as she usually gets a worm. I really think it has to be on their own terms. I think it's frightening, and stressful for them to be picked up. But when you're down on all fours, and they have an option, all mine will come to investigate. I'm sure it's a different story for a larger tortoise, like a Sulcata. But I don't think there is any smaller turtle/tortoise that would enjoy being picked up by a big giant.
