why cant tortoises and turtles be together?

Status
Not open for further replies.

dmmj

The member formerly known as captain awesome
Moderator
10 Year Member!
Joined
Aug 15, 2008
Messages
19,752
Location (City and/or State)
CA
I will also admit the risk is probably low, but in all honesty I don't see an upside to it, only downsides.
 

Squidget

Member
5 Year Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2012
Messages
30
Location (City and/or State)
Pittsburgh
Alf said:
Because turtles natural habitat is I water and Tories and a dry whic high humidity kind of reptile and it only brings disadvantages putting them together but it was a sick question to ask the public geez

I dot see how turtles natural habitats are in water. Water turtles live in water but box turtles do not. They live near water yes but they cannot swim so I do not see how this is a sick question... It may seem so to someone who doesn't know where a box turtle lives. But I assure you that to me it is a perfectly reasonable question.
 

ripper7777777

New Member
5 Year Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2011
Messages
289
Location (City and/or State)
Houston
supremelysteve said:
Squidget said:
For the record i am NOT talking about housing them together...rather hanging out together. I have a 6 inch ornate box turtle and my little baby sulcata and i have read that they cannot be around each other due to some microbe or something that they carry that will kill the other. but i cannot find out exactly how or what it is that is so bad for the other? i like to give them free time in the house and when it gets warmer in the yard...but i only have one house and yard so how can i keep it safe without keeping one caged up all the time(which of coarse would have to be the box turtle since she wont get as big as a small car lol)...is it something in their poop or what? i would love for them to meet and hang out together when my little guy (still cant decide on a dang name lol) gets a little bigger but only if it will not cause harm to either of them. can anyone tell me exactl what it is thats so bad and how it is transfered to the other, and what it does as well as how to prevent it from happening.

The only diseases I am aware of is the mycoplasma's which are a very dangerous pathogen that have been spread to california desert tortoises and to certain populations of eastern box turtles and herpes which is known to be carried by some testudo species.
Mycoplasma probably won't be carried long without expressing itself, and your turtle and tortoise are almost certainly free from it. I don't think either of your species are on the radar list for herpes either.

Many keepers do exactly what you're proposing. I don't, but many others do. It is not advisable because of the possibility one could be carrying something, but the real risk is probably somewhat low. If I had to put money on it, I'd say both will be perfectly fine. But you need to know that it is a real risk. From what you're reading in the above posts, I can see that you now know there is a risk!

The most likely problem would come from your wild-caught box turtle and could be transmitted to your tortoise. Perhaps your tortoise gets parasites from eating box turtle poop. Not life-threatening but a real world possibility.

Steve


One of the best answers I've seen on the topic.


This is one of those questions that will ruffle feathers. It's like crossing the street without looking, sure you can do it and sure you can make it just fine, but what about the one time you don't.

In the end they are your pets and in your care, you are the one that has to weigh the risks and decide.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top