I got really lucky. My brother was given some turtles and didn't want to keep them so I drove up and got them. They are all males but one is absolutely gorgeous. View attachment 215386
That male is awesome! I really hope you have success breeding him. I like those types that have the classic solid orange pattern on their shells and vibrant skin color.
Your story sounds similar to mine. I had some tortoises here and there growing up, but box turtles were my favorite thing and always had a good sized group. At one point I had groups of easterns separated by color (yellow, orange and red) and had several "screamers". They were everywhere you could look about 17 - 20 years ago. It's a different world now, as you've noticed.
Good luck in your endeavors.